Angelo of Mulberry Street: A Classic Italian Experience
A Blind Food Critic review of Angelo of Mulberry Street, a touristy but genuinely delicious Little Italy restaurant known for its pappardelle Campagnole and chicken Portobello. Now closed.<div class="more-link-wrapper"><a class="more-link" href="https://www.blindtastetest.net/new-food-critic-review-angelo-of-mulberry-st/">Continue reading<span class="screen-reader-text">Angelo of Mulberry Street: A Classic Italian Experience</span></a></div>
A Blind Food Critic review of Angelo of Mulberry Street, a touristy but genuinely delicious Little Italy restaurant known for its pappardelle Campagnole and chicken Portobello. Now closed.
New York · September 2010
Welcome back to blind blog! I apologize for my long absence, I have been busy with classes but I have returned with a new food critic review. Here is a restaurant for anyone who is a fan of Italian food.
What You Need to Know
Angelo of Mulberry St.
146 Mulberry St. (between Hester and Grand St.)
New York, NY
Update: This restaurant is now closed.
More reviews downtown
Blind Food Critic Ratings (Out of 5 Stars)
- Overall: 4.25/5 — Despite subpar service, the ambiance was enjoyable and the food was delicious and authentic, going well above expectations for a touristy Little Italy spot.
There is nothing like excellent Italian food at a local restaurant, so then why did I choose to try out a touristy establishment in Little Italy? Good question: Angelo’s actually makes delicious authentic food even though it has a reputation for being the destination of many people from out of town. Despite the subpar service, I enjoyed the ambiance; I was part of a diverse crowd of people in a relaxed setting.
My friend and I decided to split two dishes: pappardelle Campagnole (long and flat egg noodles in a sauce of tomatoes, garlic, and wild mushrooms), and pollo Portobello (chicken breast with shiitake and Portobello mushrooms in a champagne sauce). The first course to arrive was the pappardelle which went above and beyond my expectations: the pasta tasted so fresh and unlike any boxed variety I have ever tried, and was complimented perfectly by the flavors of the tangy tomatoes, mushrooms, and garlic. The sauce, in particular, was a remarkable creation which we agreed made up for the expensive price of the pasta. The next entrée was the chicken dish which was outstanding. I was impressed by the champagne sauce, it was clear that the alcohol had been burned off during the reduction phase of the cooking process which left a sweet note to the sauce that I really liked. It should not be surprising that the chicken and various mushrooms were quite fresh, but again the sauce was the highlight.
Verdict
As a restaurant which attracts many tourists, Angelo’s prices are far from cheap. However, if you are searching for some of the finest Italian food that this city has to offer, then I would encourage you to dine at Angelo’s.
Angelo of Mulberry Street Review: Quick Answers
How did the blind food critic rate Angelo’s? Overall 4.25 out of 5: delicious, authentic food well above expectations for a touristy Little Italy spot, despite subpar service.
What did he order? Pappardelle Campagnole (egg noodles with tomatoes, garlic and wild mushrooms) and pollo Portobello (chicken with shiitake and Portobello mushrooms in a champagne sauce). He called the sauces the highlight.
Is it expensive? Prices are far from cheap, but he thought the sauce made up for the price of the pasta.
Is it still open? No. Angelo of Mulberry St., at 146 Mulberry St. in Little Italy, is now closed. He reviewed it in September 2010.
Read next
ReviewSandro’s: A Roman Dining Experience — Another Italian favorite from Dan’s early reviews.
ReviewIl Mulino — When fine Italian dining lives up to its name.
ReviewMario’s on Arthur Avenue — The Bronx’s Little Italy, since 1919.
ReviewLucali Review, Brooklyn — The very first Blind Food Critic review, a mushroom pizza.